Play sand is not good for root feeding plants

Play sand is not good for root feeding plants

If you’re looking for a substrate for your planted aquarium, you may be tempted to use play sand. After all, it’s cheap and widely available. However, play sand is not the best option for root-feeding plants. In this article, we’ll explain Play sand is not good for root feeding plants? and why offer alternative substrate options.

What is Play Sand?

Play sand is a type of sand commonly used in sandboxes, playgrounds, and construction. It is usually made of crushed quartz or silica and has a fine texture.

Why Play Sand is Not Ideal for Root-Feeding Plants?

  1. Poor nutrient retention: Play sand is not designed to retain nutrients. Root-feeding plants rely on nutrients in the substrate to grow and thrive. When you use play sand as a substrate, the nutrients will leach out quickly, leaving your plants without essential nutrients.
  2. Compaction: Play sand is fine and easily compacted. This can cause problems for root-feeding plants, as compacted sand makes it difficult for roots to penetrate and absorb nutrients.
  3. Lack of air: Root-feeding plants need oxygen to grow healthy roots. However, play sand is dense and does not allow much air to pass through, causing poor root growth and poor plant health.

Alternative Substrate Options for Root-Feeding Plants

  1. Aquarium Soil: Aquarium soil is specially designed for planted tanks and provides a nutrient-rich substrate that supports healthy plant growth.
  2. Gravel: Gravel is a common choice of substrate for planted tanks, and provides good aeration and drainage. However, it is important to choose a substrate size that is not too tightly compacted.
  3. Aquatic Plant Substrate: Aquatic plant substrate is a specially designed substrate that contains nutrients and minerals for healthy plant growth.

Why Play Sand is a Poor Choice for Root Feeding Plants

When it comes to gardening or growing plants, choosing the right type of soil is critical to the overall health and growth of the plant. Root-feeding plants, in particular, need a nutrient-rich substrate that can provide essential nutrients to their root systems. Although play sand may seem like an attractive option due to its low cost and availability, it is not suitable for root-feeding plants. Here are some reasons why:

  1. Poor nutrient retention: Play sand contains small particles, which means it has less porosity and does not retain nutrients well. As a result, it cannot provide the essential nutrients that root-feeding plants need for healthy growth.
  2. Compaction: Play sand is often used for children’s play areas and is compacted to create a smooth surface. However, this compound makes it difficult for plant roots to grow and spread, ultimately stunting plant growth.
  3. pH imbalance: Play sand has a neutral pH, which is not suitable for most root-feeding plants. The ideal pH range for plants is usually between 6.0 and 7.5, and the pH of play sand can fall outside this range, causing nutrient deficiencies.
  4. Lack of Microorganisms: Play sand lacks the microorganisms necessary for healthy plant growth. These microorganisms help break down organic matter into nutrients that plants can absorb, and without them, plants cannot access these nutrients.

So, what are some alternatives to play sand for root feeding plants?

One option is to use a mixture of peat moss and perlite. Peat moss is rich in nutrients, has good water retention, and helps regulate soil pH. Perlite, on the other hand, provides aeration and drainage for roots to grow.

Another alternative is to use potting soil mixed with sand or vermiculite. Potting soil is designed to provide essential nutrients and drainage for plants, while sand or vermiculite adds additional drainage and aeration.

Also Read:


While play sand may seem like a cheap and easy option for your planted tank, it’s not ideal for root-feeding plants. It lacks the essential nutrient retention, aeration, and drainage properties that these plants require. Instead, consider using one of the alternative substrate options mentioned above for a healthy and thriving planted tank.